95 Points
"Having made no Earth Smoke in 2021 due to spring frosts and cool flowering ravaging the yield, it's a welcome return in
2022. Translucent, pure and delicately textured, this Pinot Noir shows a fine hand and the confidence to be hands off. The
wine is calm; in the mouth, it gives the impression that a hush has descended. It is attractively scented - full of dried herbs,
cherry, festive spice, violets and a hint of smoke. There's plentiful concentration without weight. The tannins are pliant,
providing the finest coating for your palate. Perhaps not as long as it could be, but I'm really nitpicking here."
Rebecca Gibb, vinous.com